Comments:
KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - Charles de Miramon - 2006-05-22
Thanks for the report. Lot have been done last quarter !!
Is somebody of the board taking care of applying KDE e.v. for the Mellon Awards ? http://rit.mellon.org/awards/
The first prize is 100 000 $, enough to fund our champaign swimming pool for 2007 Akademy.
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - Adriaan de Groot - 2006-05-22
While the Mellon awards are an attractive prize, I haven't been able to think of a way to honestly apply for the award. The criteria *to me* are unmet by KDE as a whole or any part that I can find. Other input is welcome, of course, but it needs to be in the form of a concrete application (for the award).
PS. Not everything should devolve to the board -- there are other KDE people who can take on tasks. Like .. you! Contribute!
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - gerryg - 2006-05-22
As a mere user, the top post looked right on target, so perhaps I must be missing something. It does look like it has to be KDE eV that gets the nomination:
"the importance of the organizations support to the success of the project"
but, e.g., perhaps an example relationship would be KDE eV to KOffice to ODT
"Successful efforts to increase the benefits of the project by integrating or collaborating with other open source development projects, including the adoption or encouragement of open standards"
or perhaps to Gnome and freedesktop.org?
Anyway the point is I'm happy to draft something, because that's my day job, but I'd obviously like it checked for fact and suitability. Any idea where I might publish a draft for contribution comment?
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - Adriaan de Groot - 2006-05-22
As a total pessimist, I looked at other things, like the requirements listed under "Eligibility and Award Criteria". I can't see how we fulfill item (1), even though (2) and (3) are obvious. Again, this is _my_ take on it, please don't let that stop you from explaining how we do qualify and producing a good document.
As for where to publish a draft -- try kde-promo@kde.org, that's a good and lively mailing list for the probmotion of KDE.
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - gerryg - 2006-05-22
Just before I start my 1000 words: eleigibilty criterion 1 seems to be met directly and indirectly: on "higher education" - google summer of code, largest number of sponsored students last year IIRC? less directly: "scolarly" enabling collaboration - all projects generally; promoting standards etc, and providing a platform that supports support e.g., including but not limited to Kdissert? "arts" all the music stuff? krita? thinking Zen and the art of CSS (or whatever that book is called) Quanta?
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - Charles de Miramon - 2006-05-22
I'm drafting an e-mail to the person in charge of the award to understand if they are looking for software *for* Universities and Universities Libraries or project that can be useful for their constituencies
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - Charles de Miramon - 2006-05-22
I've got an answer for the Mellon Fundation. We do not qualify. No champaign pool ;-)
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - Adriaan de Groot - 2006-05-23
"We" as in KDE as a whole? What about subprojects? [[ oh, and surely a Frenchman would write Champagne? ]] It struck me while riding my bicycle that Krita does target the arts (with its oildpaint simulations and the like) so that might be a useful subproject to reconsider.
At the same time, I'm a big fan of *critically* looking at the requirements for applications before sending something off -- I'm sure the foundation has better things to do than sift through applications that don't make sense.
Re: KDE e.v. and Mellon Awards - Johan S. Bergen - 2006-05-22
"to increase the benefits of the project by integrating or collaborating with other open source development projects, including the adoption or encouragement of open standards"
!?
Perhaps an organisation like SPI or FFII??
Or projects like Mailman, SVN, bugzilla?