AUG
3
2009

Ongoing Oxygen Icons Usability Survey: KDevelop

Every few weeks Nuno Pinheiro and the KDE Oxygen Icons team are publishing a new usability survey online to get feedback from users on the look and feel of icons. In particular, the Oxygen team is looking for feedback from individuals that have had no exposure to KDE, so if you are at home or at work, poke your friends and family and have them complete the survey, or simply take the survey yourself. The current survey is on icons for KDevelop 4 which is a major rewrite of KDevelop for KDE 4. So if you have a moment, grab someone and complete the KDevelop Icons Survey now.

Comments

Okay, just did this survey myself, and even being a coder, this was a really hard survey compared to the last one - I had to think a lot more, and I'm still not happy with all of the decisions. Wow.

Okay, good luck with this one folks.


By Troy Unrau at Mon, 2009/08/03 - 10:03pm

Yeah this one is not trivial at all and honestly I'm not expecting brilliant results as the ones we had last time, but that doesn't make it any less interesting, in fact its the other way around IMO.
We will have to probably make a few more test around this batch of icons.


By pinheiro at Mon, 2009/08/03 - 10:50pm

In the last page of the german survey there are visible (broken?) p tags and there is the untranslated text "Have fun!".


By panzi at Tue, 2009/08/04 - 1:06am

OK this is a WIP next time we will do that better thanks for spoting it.


By pinheiro at Tue, 2009/08/04 - 1:21am

I also had problems choosing the icons, none of them really jumped out as saying what they were. It might be better to go with abstract coloured/shaped shiny blobs, than an icon that seems to strongly represent another action/object/idea.

From KOffice:
new/add anything has a mini-icon of a white cross in a green circle on an icon of the thing
open file has an open blue folder with a icon of a thing poking out (I'm not happy with this one)

Suggestions:

Objects:
Function/Method - an italic "f(x)" or button or 'action'
Variable/Attribute - an italic x or text-box or slider
Define/Constant - a capital X or label or italic x with padlock
Project - (tricky there are lots of different ones) a folder or a folder of a window/panel, a program script, a folder, etc.
Empty Project - like empty glass folder, light grey program script/text file, window/panel...
Template Project - half full glass, half blue half grey
Favourite - yellow star

Action mini-icons:
Add/New - white plus sign in green circle or green +
Delete - white minus sign in red circle or red X
Update/Open - while hand-finger on amber circle or amber O
Close - kiss goodbye X or save's floppy disk
Find/Jump-to - binoculars
Zoom/Details - magnifying glass
Import - white arrow into object container
Export - white arrow out of object container
Wizard - magic wand or lightning

Quick-open - open file-folder
Project (Development) - folder of text doc, window/panel (with edit pencil)
Project (Development) Template - half full folder
Function - "f(x)"
Jump to definition - binoculars or |


By Purple-Bobby at Tue, 2009/08/04 - 2:22am

There's a little typo on the first page: The page says "Runing" where it should say "Running" :)

Now that I got my first feedback out:

I really like these surveys - they are a very easy way for people to become active, at least a little bit. So they are a great way to gain entry - and I can also do them when I'm very short of time.

Many thanks!


By Arne Babenhauserheide at Tue, 2009/08/04 - 6:31am

Also, "excelent" should have two "l".

I know that KDE 3 is no longer really supported, but I found it a little sad that I had to fill in this survey with firefox as it wouldn't work in konqueror (kde 3.5.10 - clicking on the icons didn't have any effect). It's not as if a survey like that requires highly advanced javascript tricks...

Also, instead of just putting the icon name I think it may have been better to write a short sentence saying what they should do. For example I had no idea what the "project development" icon is supposed to do.


By tendays at Tue, 2009/08/04 - 10:29pm

Also, instead of just putting the icon name I think it may have been better to write a short sentence saying what they should do. For example I had no idea what the "project development" icon is supposed to do.

same problem here..


By mxttie at Fri, 2009/08/14 - 10:38am

Sorry, but for most of the questions I was absolutely unable to choose an Icon: no one would fit !


By lbayle at Tue, 2009/08/04 - 8:32am